July-August 2010
    Bookmark and Share

The Dominoes of Complacency and the Firefighting Mind-Set

By Dave McGrail

When firefighters are injured or killed in the line of duty, the events leading up to these tragedies are usually based on numerous factors. I like to compare it to a line of dominoes falling (figure 1).

Figure 1. Once the dominoes of complacency begin to fall, they are hard to stop, and can result in firefighter injuries and deaths.

 

We’ve all been there and seen the fireground dominoes fall, one after another. Often, a good leader steps in and makes the necessary decisions to recover from a bad start and ultimately stop the dominoes. Sometimes it’s just plain fire service luck that leads to a tragedy-free conclusion. Unfortunately, if your operations are based on luck, eventually, your luck is going to run out.

We see it time and again, with statements like “suddenly and without warning the building collapsed.” Chief Vincent Dunn (retired deputy chief, FDNY) and the late Francis Brannigan (author of Building Construction for the Fire Service), in their attempt to educate the fire service, have told us time and again that the collapse of a burning building, especially one with a lightweight truss, should certainly not come as a surprise to any of us.

Arriving at the floor of alarm, opening the elevator doors, and encountering smoke and/or fire would certainly be a surprise to a couple of guys from the parks department, the city librarian, or even a couple of cops. Firefighters, however, work for the fire department. Our primary mission is to respond to and extinguish fires. The company officer who takes his crew members directly to the floor of alarm demonstrates a very weak mind-set and eventually will get someone injured or possibly even killed. Those members might like their officer in the short run because he makes their life easier by not having them stop the elevator two floors below and walk up. But believe me; they have little or no respect for him at all, simply based on the fact that he’s not protecting them. Surprised is the last thing firefighters should be upon encountering smoke or fire at the floor of alarm.

The primary responsibility of a company officer is to keep the members under his command as safe as possible. This is not an easy proposition, based on the fact that firefighters operate in very unsafe conditions. After all, we’re talking about going after a fire on the upper floors of a high-rise building. The firefighter safety and survival premise is based on the principles of developing, maintaining, and practicing good habits, plain and simple. Furthermore, those good habits are not just applied once in a while, but every time, and at every operation. I firmly believe that the actions firefighters usually take, good habits or bad, are the same actions they will take when it really counts. Those who normally take the elevator directly up to the floor of alarm will most likely do it the night that there’s really a fire on the other side of those elevator doors (figure 2).

Figure 2. Taking an elevator no closer than two floors below a reported fire floor or floor of alarm is a good habit, which equates to firefighter safety and survival.

 

The most important characteristic that a firefighter possesses is his mind-set. A firefighter’s mind-set is based on a compilation of factors, including his attitude, preparedness, and an overall belief that a serious event will happen. Maybe not today, certainly not every day, but eventually, someday, it will happen.

What is it? Well, it can be almost anything from a serious house fire, to a large commercial building fire. It might be the major collapse of a large, occupied auditorium or maybe even a plane crash. It can also be a serious fire in a high-rise or standpipe-equipped building. A truly dedicated firefighter is always prepared for the worst, and must be prepared for almost anything.

Figure 3.The possibility of a serious fire in a high-rise or standpipe-equipped building exists in many large cities and small communities.

 

Over the years, I have found that most firefighters are familiar with the basics of what has to be, and what should be, done at a given event. As human beings, however, we sometimes cut out some of the elements of a comprehensive operation due to complacency and laziness. For example, even the newest firefighter who reads my book won’t be surprised that I recommend exercising serious discipline when using elevators. One of the basic rules of high-rise operations is to never take an elevator directly to a reported fire floor or floor of alarm. This is nothing new, just good, basic, common-sense procedures. Have you, or has any one you know, ever witnessed firefighters bending this rule, or totally disregarding it?

What if I were to say that many fire departments in the United States currently are equipped to deliver less water at a fire on the 20th floor of a high-rise building than would be acceptable at a modern vehicle fire? It’s absolutely true. Far too many fire departments have a high-rise/standpipe hose pack equipped with 1¾-inch hose (and in some frightening cases, 1½-inch hose) with an automatic combination fog nozzle. This complement of weapons, supplied from a low-pressure standpipe system, especially one with built in, automatic pressure reducing valves (PRV’s), and a flow of less than 100 GPM, possibly much less, is likely a reality. A fire department that sends its firefighters into high-rise buildings, with this equipment is on a collision course with disaster and tragedy.

The scope of the problem is much greater than the obvious tactical and equipment error. It also encompasses an overall, widespread organizational complacency and lack of proper mind-set from the top down. When was the last time your department flow-tested its high-rise/standpipe nozzles at the low discharge pressures typical of most standpipe systems? Many nozzles, but specifically the automatic combination type, can truly be deceiving and may be a deadly choice for standpipe operations. It all starts at the top and the priority must be firefighting.


This article was excerpted from Chief McGrail’s book, Firefighting Operations in High-Rise and Standpipe-Equipped Buildings. To purchase the book return to the Main Page and click on the book icon in the Firenuggets Bookstore


© Copyright Firenuggets.com 2010 • Click here for Terms and Conditions of Use

Home<•••SIGN OUT

RETURN TO CURRENT ISSUE INDEX